Differences: HCP Vault Secrets vs. HCP Vault Dedicated vs. HashiCorp Vault Community
Overview Table
| Feature/Aspect | HCP Vault Secrets | HCP Vault Dedicated | HashiCorp Vault Community |
|---|---|---|---|
| Managed By | HashiCorp | HashiCorp | User/self-hosted |
| Delivery Model | SaaS, multi-tenant | SaaS, single-tenant | Software/app, self-managed |
| Target Use Case | Simple/centralized secrets management | Advanced, production-grade secrets, PKI, DR | General secrets management |
| Certificate and Key Management | No | Yes | Yes (basic) |
| Namespaces, Advanced Policies | No | Yes | No |
| Performance Replication | No | Yes | No |
| Audit Logging | Basic | Advanced, automated | Basic |
| High Availability | Managed | Yes | Manual (HA requires config) |
| Integrations/Sync Engines | Can sync secrets to third-party services | Advanced integrations | Community & limited integrations |
| Cost | Lower, simple pricing | Higher, tiered pricing | Free |
| Operational Overhead | None | Minimal (fully managed) | High (user manages everything) |
| Suitable For | Simple, fast setup, small teams | Enterprise/production-grade, compliance | Any, POC, dev/test, small prod |
HCP Vault Secrets
- Focuses on simplicity: Provides a quick way to store and centrally manage secrets (API keys, passwords) with automated rotation and audit trails.
- Key features: Static and dynamic secrets, secrets sync to third-party platforms (e.g., AWS Secrets Manager, GitHub Actions), lifecycle management, CLI and web UI access, audit change tracking.
- Limitations: Lacks advanced enterprise-grade features like namespaces, fine-grained policies, and performance replication. Best for straightforward use cases.
- Status: Being decommissioned—users are recommended to migrate to HCP Vault Dedicated or self-managed solutions.
HCP Vault Dedicated
- Enterprise, production-ready: A fully managed, single-tenant service based on Vault Enterprise, hosted and operated by HashiCorp in the cloud.
- Key features: Namespaces, advanced policy and access controls, audit logging, PKI/certificate management, performance and disaster recovery (DR) replication, high availability, automatic upgrades and backups, and advanced integrations.
- Cloud-native: Deployable on AWS/Azure, integrates tightly with other cloud resources.
- Audience: Organizations with complex security, compliance, and scaling needs that don’t want to manage operational overhead.
HashiCorp Vault Community Edition
- Self-hosted, open core: Free software deployed, operated, and managed by the user.
- Key features: Core Vault functions for secrets management, dynamic secrets, data encryption, and identity-based access. Basic audit logging, authentication, and plugin support.
- Limitations: Does not include enterprise features (namespaces, advanced replication, control groups, etc.). Scaling, availability, upgrades, and recovery must be built and managed by the user.
- Best for: POCs, small teams, developer environments, cost-sensitive solutions, or those preferring full control over their infrastructure.
Summary by Use Case
- Choose HCP Vault Secrets for a simple, SaaS-managed, central “secrets as a service”—but note its upcoming deprecation.
- Choose HCP Vault Dedicated for robust, production-use, highly secure managed Vault with advanced features.
- Choose Vault Community Edition if you need a free, open-source option and are able to manage everything yourself.
For organizations prioritizing simple onboarding, HCP Vault Secrets (if still available) offers minimal overhead but limited depth. HCP Vault Dedicated is best for teams needing enterprise features without wanting to self-manage. Vault Community gives maximum control but requires significant operational investment.
I’m a DevOps/SRE/DevSecOps/Cloud Expert passionate about sharing knowledge and experiences. I have worked at Cotocus. I share tech blog at DevOps School, travel stories at Holiday Landmark, stock market tips at Stocks Mantra, health and fitness guidance at My Medic Plus, product reviews at TrueReviewNow , and SEO strategies at Wizbrand.
Do you want to learn Quantum Computing?
Please find my social handles as below;
Rajesh Kumar Personal Website
Rajesh Kumar at YOUTUBE
Rajesh Kumar at INSTAGRAM
Rajesh Kumar at X
Rajesh Kumar at FACEBOOK
Rajesh Kumar at LINKEDIN
Rajesh Kumar at WIZBRAND
